Author Topic: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?  (Read 2787 times)

Offline poorprincess

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 209
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #15 on: November 20, 2024, 09:31:45 PM »
I only looked for short term contact - so here's hoping!

Offline serenejoy

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 293
  • walk by faith, not by sight
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #16 on: November 20, 2024, 09:51:19 PM »
what did she give you as far as timing? I hope it happens! Do come back and share with us <3

Offline Mina

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 296
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #17 on: November 20, 2024, 11:23:32 PM »
I read with pretty raver readings from 2021-2023 ish. I really enjoyed this reader but I felt she led me astray at times. She did get two predictions dates right but every other prediction was so general 2-3 weeks, 4-6 weeks. And while I do believe in manifesting it kinda pissed me off when she said I could manifest it (like that was her way of giving me negative news)- yet here I am a year later still trying to do just that- so I’m glad she blocked me when I gave her a 4 Star review saying prediction didn’t happen (out of the many that didn’t). It was rough, but I felt this helped me phase out a lot of psychics who were my “reasonably priced psychics” (however I think she is about $6-$7 min and she was off on too much timing for that). I even read with her about other former poi to test things out and it seemed like it was inline, just not really thorough enough for my satisfaction (which I bet I sound egotistical)
But I did really like her, she was so gentle and sweet but I felt led astray and disappointed with her timing.

Offline Mattsmom

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 101
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #18 on: November 21, 2024, 03:49:18 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

Here's the caveat with this kind of wish:  and yes, OP's point is valid.

Many advisors could be constantly scouring each others' listings and see those details, then have those clients read with them.  It's akin to note taking and sharing with other advisors except it removes that link of even needing to interact with each other.


Offline sai07

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 164
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #19 on: November 21, 2024, 04:28:46 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Offline serenejoy

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 293
  • walk by faith, not by sight
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #20 on: November 21, 2024, 04:34:00 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

Offline sai07

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 164
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #21 on: November 21, 2024, 04:58:45 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

I was literally thinking this today bc some readers have just fed off what I said and some even changed their prediction based on me changing my mind about the POI, for example, if I say to them, I am very frustrated and thinking of walking away, they will echo that sentiment. And then they use the 'free will' card. Yes, everyone has free will but ....shouldn't a prediction stand despite free-will? Isn't there really one outcome that unfolds? Like you're either with the person or you're not at the end of it all. You either get the job or you don't. That's why I think long-term predictions, people just can't seem to get them right.

Sorry, went off an a mini-rant, LOL. Feel free to provide another POV.

Offline serenejoy

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 293
  • walk by faith, not by sight
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #22 on: November 21, 2024, 05:14:47 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

I was literally thinking this today bc some readers have just fed off what I said and some even changed their prediction based on me changing my mind about the POI, for example, if I say to them, I am very frustrated and thinking of walking away, they will echo that sentiment. And then they use the 'free will' card. Yes, everyone has free will but ....shouldn't a prediction stand despite free-will? Isn't there really one outcome that unfolds? Like you're either with the person or you're not at the end of it all. You either get the job or you don't. That's why I think long-term predictions, people just can't seem to get them right.

Sorry, went off an a mini-rant, LOL. Feel free to provide another POV.

No, you're good! I honestly get that and feel the same way a lot. What I've kind of experienced is this....

Scenario 1
I have a positive outlook on my relationship with POI and believe that by February we will have things sorted out and he will commit. I read with some psychics and they give me a positive reading and a "2" for a timeframe of things progressing.

Scenario 2
I have a doubt/nagging feeling that my POI has feelings for his ex and will reconcile with her because he has distanced himself a bit. I read with a psychic and they tell me there is another woman and he is trying to figure things out, etc.

Scenario 3
I am hoping that POI changes jobs so that he can have a better work/life balance and be able to spend more time together. I read with a psychic and suddenly work comes up and him wanting to either change jobs or having the opportunity for a new one comes up.

I know it was vague in some of these expressions, but I'm sure you get the point. It's happened to me quite often.

Offline sai07

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 164
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #23 on: November 21, 2024, 05:39:43 PM »
So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

I was literally thinking this today bc some readers have just fed off what I said and some even changed their prediction based on me changing my mind about the POI, for example, if I say to them, I am very frustrated and thinking of walking away, they will echo that sentiment. And then they use the 'free will' card. Yes, everyone has free will but ....shouldn't a prediction stand despite free-will? Isn't there really one outcome that unfolds? Like you're either with the person or you're not at the end of it all. You either get the job or you don't. That's why I think long-term predictions, people just can't seem to get them right.

Sorry, went off an a mini-rant, LOL. Feel free to provide another POV.

No, you're good! I honestly get that and feel the same way a lot. What I've kind of experienced is this....

Scenario 1
I have a positive outlook on my relationship with POI and believe that by February we will have things sorted out and he will commit. I read with some psychics and they give me a positive reading and a "2" for a timeframe of things progressing.

Scenario 2
I have a doubt/nagging feeling that my POI has feelings for his ex and will reconcile with her because he has distanced himself a bit. I read with a psychic and they tell me there is another woman and he is trying to figure things out, etc.

Scenario 3
I am hoping that POI changes jobs so that he can have a better work/life balance and be able to spend more time together. I read with a psychic and suddenly work comes up and him wanting to either change jobs or having the opportunity for a new one comes up.

I know it was vague in some of these expressions, but I'm sure you get the point. It's happened to me quite often.

Yes, I have experienced the same.

Offline flora0250

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 580
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #24 on: November 21, 2024, 06:25:31 PM »
So glad that this post has brought up some good info and conversation on this point. Very grateful for the replies and discussion!

I think I’m learning about myself that … this is going to sound wild but I think it’s true more and more …

I’m not actually as interested in knowing the future with a given POI AS MUCH as I’m interested in knowing once and for all if ANYONE can actually predict future events. Or maybe that’s tipping the scale a little too far but they’re probably just about equal!

And that’s a huge reason why I’m like okay let me take explicit notes. Let me try this person. Let me try that person. I have a bit of an OCD side to myself and this is another behavior that falls into that category for me. But it’s special bc it also has all the emotional / loneliness element - haha soooo fun.

So - yes actually, I am not sure that ANYONE can predict the future. I’m still not really sure about empathic abilities because I would need to confirm that my POI has felt the thing that was said they felt at the time it was said. And that’s just not something I’ve been able to confirm although it does seeeeeeem to match a lot of times with what I know. So I think there’s a possibility for that to be a true ability.

Remote viewing? DEFINITELY. Don’t know how that happens and have only come across a small handful that are genuinely good at it but I have had a few people where it’s like okay definitely they can actually see or somehow pick up on this random thing.

But predicting the future???

Actually no, there is one person, Shelly, who is on ATA and I posted about before as well as a long time ago - I have absolutely had specific markers she had said happen. So that definitely counts as in this person predicted this would happen and it did. I’ll repeat an example. She told me I would have someone talk to me about walnuts - specifically cracking walnuts. And a couple weeks after the reading I’m at the dentist after having some work done and my dentist looks me straight in the eye and says “you should be fine but maybe don’t go cracking any walnuts on that tooth just yet.”  I’m telling you I just about fell out of my chair. She also predicted that I would see a specific person by name (and not a common name) in an unusual place and a few hours later I saw that specific person walking down the street randomly as I drove by somewhere completely out of place where I would normally see her.

So! Yes, I think in that case I have to give her credit for predicting an actual event that happened in the future. But they were markers and what I actually asked about that was tied to the markers NEVER HAPPENED. So here’s the thing - I wasn’t asking about nuts. I wasn’t asking about this coworker. I didn’t give a crap about either of those things but they happened.

So this is where I start to wonder if the less we are attached to something the more likely we could be getting an accurate future prediction reading- in some cases. Honestly I think most people are complete fakes and good cold readers.

So what good is that though??? lol.

So that’s my take fwiw. But I am still calling people and testing things out and taking notes and collecting data on this. Because I am that darn stubborn I guess! 

Offline poorprincess

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 209
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #25 on: November 21, 2024, 07:51:10 PM »
WELL! I am happy to report that all three were correct on the contact prediction as well as the details of our conversation. My big guy texted me this morning saying he wanted to stop by. He came over, we both apologized for our disagreement and are in a good place again!

A lot of great conversation on this thread. This was my first psychic binge in quite some time and with this new guy. I will be back! For now, he's making me lunch :)

hugs, friends!

Offline love123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 87
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #26 on: November 21, 2024, 07:58:05 PM »
WELL! I am happy to report that all three were correct on the contact prediction as well as the details of our conversation. My big guy texted me this morning saying he wanted to stop by. He came over, we both apologized for our disagreement and are in a good place again!

A lot of great conversation on this thread. This was my first psychic binge in quite some time and with this new guy. I will be back! For now, he's making me lunch :)

hugs, friends!

That’s great news!! Happy they all worked for you :)

Offline sai07

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 164
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #27 on: November 21, 2024, 08:00:15 PM »
WELL! I am happy to report that all three were correct on the contact prediction as well as the details of our conversation. My big guy texted me this morning saying he wanted to stop by. He came over, we both apologized for our disagreement and are in a good place again!

A lot of great conversation on this thread. This was my first psychic binge in quite some time and with this new guy. I will be back! For now, he's making me lunch :)

hugs, friends!

Glad it worked out for you!

Offline dragonflyer

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 100
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #28 on: November 21, 2024, 08:01:16 PM »
My strategy is always to give the minimum information to readers. For example, the moment the reader pick up the phone, I would go straight asking "what's so and so thinking about our relationship/connection?" even when we are not talking or separated and there is no relationship. Good ones will pick up there is a separation.
If the reader asked me "when was the last communication?" I would say "a while ago" or "quite some time", instead of giving them a specific time.
Sometimes the reader would test me with "is there a female energy around this person?" "do they xxx?" "are they doing xxx?" I always say "I don't know. Please let me know whatever you feel."
I will also ask open-ended questions, instead of giving them options to choose.


So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

I was literally thinking this today bc some readers have just fed off what I said and some even changed their prediction based on me changing my mind about the POI, for example, if I say to them, I am very frustrated and thinking of walking away, they will echo that sentiment. And then they use the 'free will' card. Yes, everyone has free will but ....shouldn't a prediction stand despite free-will? Isn't there really one outcome that unfolds? Like you're either with the person or you're not at the end of it all. You either get the job or you don't. That's why I think long-term predictions, people just can't seem to get them right.

Sorry, went off an a mini-rant, LOL. Feel free to provide another POV.

Offline flora0250

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 580
Re: Readers w/feedback that predictions happened?
« Reply #29 on: November 21, 2024, 08:11:15 PM »

Those are great suggestions and come backs - definitely going to use them! I have gone with “what do you see about me and so and so reconnecting” or “what’s the potential for a relationship with” but even that gives too much info. I also have always fallen into telling them when our last contact is. Which in retrospect is foolish of me.

My strategy is always to give the minimum information to readers. For example, the moment the reader pick up the phone, I would go straight asking "what's so and so thinking about our relationship/connection?" even when we are not talking or separated and there is no relationship. Good ones will pick up there is a separation.
If the reader asked me "when was the last communication?" I would say "a while ago" or "quite some time", instead of giving them a specific time.
Sometimes the reader would test me with "is there a female energy around this person?" "do they xxx?" "are they doing xxx?" I always say "I don't know. Please let me know whatever you feel."
I will also ask open-ended questions, instead of giving them options to choose.


So when I’m trying to find a new reader to try, what I’m looking for is if their feedback states that predictions have passed. Not “oh they’re so helpful” or “oh they were accurate” but specifically that predictions passed and the more detail the better. And not from the same accounts over and over. Anyone have any recommendations that have that kind of feedback?

I have taken a chance on a few I never tried before and will advise if any predictions come to pass.

This may be a totally unpopular opinion but after all my readings, I just don't think, at least on Keen, there are people that can predict the future. I am not saying there are people that do not have a gift, I just don't believe anyone can see that far out with accuracy and precision every single time. I look for the same, Flora, but I have given up.

To Mattsmom's point, I sometimes do wonder if readers note-share bc sometimes I have readers tell me the exact same things + timelines and then of course, things don't pan out even though I think, well, oh, I heard that consistent feedback from a number of readers.

Interesting take, I often wonder if readers are simply just reading our mind/thoughts as oppose to predicting a future outcome.

I was literally thinking this today bc some readers have just fed off what I said and some even changed their prediction based on me changing my mind about the POI, for example, if I say to them, I am very frustrated and thinking of walking away, they will echo that sentiment. And then they use the 'free will' card. Yes, everyone has free will but ....shouldn't a prediction stand despite free-will? Isn't there really one outcome that unfolds? Like you're either with the person or you're not at the end of it all. You either get the job or you don't. That's why I think long-term predictions, people just can't seem to get them right.

Sorry, went off an a mini-rant, LOL. Feel free to provide another POV.