Spiritualist Reader (Cookie)

[Kate]

Has anyone else been underwhelmed by their reading with her? Not that she did not touch on some things that I could verify but she didn't give me too many real answers on my questions and I was not entirely sure she wasn't mixing up the past of what has happened with my POI with what is current and what will happen. And she kept repeating herself and she said the same thing as someone else mentioned above, that he is out on dates all the time which I know is not true at all. She also said I could trust him but then kept saying I will find out things that make me question his integrity and that he gives half truths and hides a lot so how can he be trustworthy then? I was really excited to read with her after all these posts but I don't think I will ever bother again, I have gotten much more info and clarity with Oracle of the Sea and some other readers I have called lately.

I was Totally underwhelmed by my reading... and yup, pretty much exactly how you described it - I mean even the details...  Were you calling about the same man I was???  lol - call cost me $156 US and I am in Canada so likely over $200... not worth it and I won't call her again...  I am trying really hard not to call at all anymore or at least not for a long time (after my call with that I am waiting for with Judi) but she is off my list.

Yes similar details and similar reading. She said I would find everything she had told me through social media.. but that has been completely incorrect as well. I can't verify any of it.. and I've tried! Very expensve reading and I regret it.

So seems to be at least three similar (very) readings all very recently?  I am not saying she doesn't have talent, but I am almost relieved as I have been second guessing my own intuition and everything else ever since.

Well she was completely off re the dating/sleeping around situation. It's not only out of character for the person I was enquiring about.. he is v v reserved physically with people.. and he doesn't communicate with anyone on social media (FB, online etc) .. he is an extremely private person... she said I would find out via social media.. but that's been incorrect also.  I have no doubt he is socialising with friends, and I'm sure he is flirting as we all do.. but sleeping and dating profusely as Cookie made out?? 

[Luckystar]

Cookie is one of those whose readings make sense as things start to happen.

Cookie does get some things right that happen later, but I do think she fills in gaps sometimes...by either guessing or jumping to her own conclusions... but I would say she has been about 80% right for me over the last 4-5 years. Also she tends to be better with general predictions. I have noticed her accuracy drops when inquiring about specific people, especially about their emotions.

[Member5]

Has anyone else been underwhelmed by their reading with her? Not that she did not touch on some things that I could verify but she didn't give me too many real answers on my questions and I was not entirely sure she wasn't mixing up the past of what has happened with my POI with what is current and what will happen. And she kept repeating herself and she said the same thing as someone else mentioned above, that he is out on dates all the time which I know is not true at all. She also said I could trust him but then kept saying I will find out things that make me question his integrity and that he gives half truths and hides a lot so how can he be trustworthy then? I was really excited to read with her after all these posts but I don't think I will ever bother again, I have gotten much more info and clarity with Oracle of the Sea and some other readers I have called lately.

I was Totally underwhelmed by my reading... and yup, pretty much exactly how you described it - I mean even the details...  Were you calling about the same man I was???  lol - call cost me $156 US and I am in Canada so likely over $200... not worth it and I won't call her again...  I am trying really hard not to call at all anymore or at least not for a long time (after my call with that I am waiting for with Judi) but she is off my list.

Yes similar details and similar reading. She said I would find everything she had told me through social media.. but that has been completely incorrect as well. I can't verify any of it.. and I've tried! Very expensve reading and I regret it.

Yes I spent the same and was really disappointed after all the rave reviews I read. She told me the communication was going to get worse between POI and myself and when I asked when she said pretty much from now and that it would not get better until next spring and that I would be waiting two years for this to be a relationship and that we would have 2 or 3 times it almost happened before it does. Actually we have known each other for a few years and this is our third attempt at dating but the most serious and we have been talking nonstop since the reading and there is no way I would wait years on anyone. And now seeing she told the same things to others about theirs, well I put in a satisfaction guarantee request. I really wish I would have listened to myself and not accepted the call when it came through.

[Apalm831]

Just doing my due diligence to update on something that happened. Cookie predicted I would meet a man who was culturally Muslim, which did happen. In my second to last reading with her, about the OLD guy, she specifically said 'He's going to block you.' I was really confused, I haven't been contacting him, he hasn't blocked me and doubt he would. So, this confused me and she said it quite literally out of nowhere (sometimes she interjects with something very important I find) She said if I kept persisting on something , he would block me, but I was 100% sure she was talking about the old guy.

Well, new guy imploded. Way worse than any 'relationship' I've been in in several years, especially something so brief. We both said pretty crappy things to each and it was insanely vitriolic on his side. Then he blocked me, across the the board. Phone, social media, etc. This guy had been very intensely chasing after me but I did a lot to push him away (dating PTSD) and he said it wrecked him, made him angry, etc. Then I tried to come back around, feeling bad, and it backfired.

So, then what she said made sense. Just not at the time. She also brought this up the day before he blocked me, but she didn't know it was him. She said 'Someone who blocked you comes up...' I thought maybe someone from the past because me and new guy were still talking.

Cookie mixes up energies a lot and can muddle the past and present and future a bit. I just thought this might be some interesting insight into how she works. Recording her and going back to find info like this is always amazing to me.

[Member5]

I'm glad she worked for so many of you, but I am also glad Keen gave me back most of my money from that call. I have already had confirmation that several things she told me about my POI were completely wrong and I think some other things she was insistent would happen she mixed up with what has already happened. Which is fine, I would rather someone be wrong than right when it comes to telling me someone has values and morals that don't match mine.

[Apalm831]

I'm glad she worked for so many of you, but I am also glad Keen gave me back most of my money from that call. I have already had confirmation that several things she told me about my POI were completely wrong and I think some other things she was insistent would happen she mixed up with what has already happened. Which is fine, I would rather someone be wrong than right when it comes to telling me someone has values and morals that don't match mine.

She mixes up people and times all the time. I think she has trouble navigating through what she's seeing. A lot of the time I'll think she's wrong, or what she says doesn't make sense and when I go back it's true but a different person or it's something that has already happened.

She seems to identify people based on appearance. Most of the people I date seriously have very very similar qualities so, I think it's tricky for me with her.

[Kate]

I'm glad she worked for so many of you, but I am also glad Keen gave me back most of my money from that call. I have already had confirmation that several things she told me about my POI were completely wrong and I think some other things she was insistent would happen she mixed up with what has already happened. Which is fine, I would rather someone be wrong than right when it comes to telling me someone has values and morals that don't match mine.

I'm reassured by your post as I had the same experience.. although did not ask for a refund.. I know the things she shared with me re my POI are not accurate.. however, I'm not sure what or who she was seeing.. I don't think for a moment she was spinning me a line or trying to mislead me..just relaying what she was seeing.. 

[Member5]

Kate, she said a couple things that had already happened and I told her so but she just insisted it was going to happen again, and that would be impossible. I have had other readers say things similar but then when I say oh that already happened they don't insist it will be the case again. She was very nice, and I took notes but for how long it took at her rates, I ended up not getting too much info really.

[Shayalay]

I thought she got the past and future mixed up in my first reading with her but guess what, she didn't. The past repeated itself. This was something big that at the time was completely unforeseeable.

[patu005]

I have to say.. 2 things she said happened, they are minor and when we spoke didn't make sense but suddenly they are happening in front of my eyes. That's pretty cool I think and these were things I necessary didn't ask about. Still waiting major predictions.

[Apalm831]

Has anyone had this experience--with my first read with Cookie on a certain person she was off like a shot and had a lot of info. With one person, the situation was dynamic and things happened in between readings to change that, but with others it didn't however her second or third reading regarding a specific person had drastically shifted. Has anyone had that experience and if so which turned out to be more accurate? The initial reading or the readings later on?

[Bostongirl]

Things change... all the time nothing is set in stone.

[Sooshi]

Just doing my due diligence to update on something that happened. Cookie predicted I would meet a man who was culturally Muslim, which did happen. In my second to last reading with her, about the OLD guy, she specifically said 'He's going to block you.' I was really confused, I haven't been contacting him, he hasn't blocked me and doubt he would. So, this confused me and she said it quite literally out of nowhere (sometimes she interjects with something very important I find) She said if I kept persisting on something , he would block me, but I was 100% sure she was talking about the old guy.

Well, new guy imploded. Way worse than any 'relationship' I've been in in several years, especially something so brief. We both said pretty crappy things to each and it was insanely vitriolic on his side. Then he blocked me, across the the board. Phone, social media, etc. This guy had been very intensely chasing after me but I did a lot to push him away (dating PTSD) and he said it wrecked him, made him angry, etc. Then I tried to come back around, feeling bad, and it backfired.

So, then what she said made sense. Just not at the time. She also brought this up the day before he blocked me, but she didn't know it was him. She said 'Someone who blocked you comes up...' I thought maybe someone from the past because me and new guy were still talking.

Cookie mixes up energies a lot and can muddle the past and present and future a bit. I just thought this might be some interesting insight into how she works. Recording her and going back to find info like this is always amazing to me.

Wow. Sounds like you dodged a bullet with him.

[Luckystar]

Has she ever given any of you a description of your future life partner? (if you are single)

[Apalm831]

Things change... all the time nothing is set in stone.

Right. The question is—what was more accurate
The initial read or readings further along