I have been in Cookies line forever. QoC was a fail for me. There was nothing I could validate and she was very negative. I don't want sugar coating AT ALL, but she just gave me negative vibes. Like even with good predictions, she made everything sound bad anyway. I always hung up more upset.
I have to say the same about QOC, and I can handle being told the truth as I was told not so great news last night and knew it to be true. But the reader actually gave me evidence and validations that were true as to why things couldn't be smooth sailing if I were to get back with the ex. With QOC she just said "he can't commit", and when I asked her why, what the reasons are she feels for that, she just said "he just can't commit". She seemed to ask questions and get mixed up.. I agree with others, she's too negative on relationships and she really was vague and seemed to struggle with me. The only good I can say about her is she was nice and patient with me, and perhaps the third parties are accurate (I couldn't confirm). But she has told multiple people the "you'll only be friends he can't commit" line, and I feel she plays the safe game and is more realistic and negative about relationships.. Doesn't necessarily mean she's honest and she was right all along because she gave bad news. I'm not saying she is poor and can't read for anybody, however.
Cookie I haven't read with, but am 58th on the list and do wanna try her, so can't make comment on her, yet.