"Both have the reputation for being accurate and free of fairy tale stories..." -Yes, but you can't really lump sum them into one as both readers have different abilities.
It really depends on what you're looking for. I go to Kisha for general readings. Nobody beats Kisha when it comes to generals, hands down. I go to LP for a strong empath as that's her strongest suit, though it states she possess the 3 C's. If I want to look into how the person really thinks - she's excellent at this.
When it comes to predictions, both have made correct, dare I say one out of the two bigger picture outcomes. Both predicted a relationship wasn't going to work and was going to end. Kisha said in a 2 - correct, it did happen in a 2. LP no timeframe given but was adamant it wasn't going to work, and that did happen so correct.
They both offered this prediction on their own without me asking about it. So both correct on outcome. The only other reader to predict the same outcome was MsLisaM and she gave me two specific months for it to happen and correct. So there you have it.
I like them both. Both accurate, ethical and pleasant to read with. My tops, thus far.
Both gave me the same reading but LP gave me more of where the poi's head was at. LP was also more thorough on past details. Kisha was able to throw me descriptions of people.
Kisha: general readings, timeframes, predictions.
LP: empath, specific questions (doesn't do generals), no timeframes - she will give it to you only if it jumps out in the reading. For example she'll say 'why do I keep getting a 2?' or 'either in 3 days or 3...' without me ever asking and it turns out to be spot on correct.
So to answer and sum up your question, as far as predictions goes, both readers have been correct on a major outcome.